Are you looking for a thoughtful present for a knitter? Surprise knitting boxes are the perfect choice. They combine the joy of creativity with the delight of receiving something special, making it perfect for birthdays, holidays, or just because.
Whether you're gifting to a complete beginner or a yarn-loving pro, these curated boxes include everything from luxury fibres to patterns and accessories, beautifully wrapped and ready to go. Many come with gifting options, personal notes, and flexible subscription models.
Our favourite surprise knitting box is by Knit In A Box. Keep on reading to find out why we ranked it first in the list we have curated.
The 8 Best Surprise Knitting Boxes For a Gift in 2025
| Brand Name |
Price |
Skill Level |
Yarn Type |
Gifting Option |
Avg Rating |
| Knit In A Box |
From £21.24 |
All levels |
Wool blends |
✅ |
⭐️ 4.8 |
| Little Skein |
From £30 |
All levels |
Wool |
❌ |
N/A |
| Crochet Society |
From £24.99 |
All levels |
Not specified |
✅ |
2.4 |
| Cookston Crafts |
From £20 |
All levels |
Merino blend |
❌ |
4.6
|
| Stitches & Cream |
From £24 |
Intermediate |
Wool |
❌ |
N/A |
| Hebridean Tea Store |
From £30 |
Beginner - Intermediate |
Wool blend |
❌ |
4.6 |
| Dina’s Home of Crafts |
From £5.70 |
All levels |
Wool |
❌ |
4.3
|
| Lauren Aston Designs |
From £30 |
Beginner - Intermediate |
Merino wool |
❌ |
N/A |
Knit In A Box (Our Top Pick)
Knit In A Box is the number one knitting subscription box in the UK and a leading choice for surprise knitting boxes. With various all-in-one knitting kits available, you have the flexibility to choose a surprise box that suits the recipient’s interests.
What’s Inside:
- Premium yarn in themed monthly colours
- Printed pattern
- Surprise accessories
Best for:
- All skill levels
- Thoughtful, ready-to-send gifts
Why We Like It:
- Eco-friendly packaging makes it feel gift-ready
- Includes everything a knitter needs to get started
- Offers separate options for different project types
- Their knitting boxes for gifting are super convenient
👉 Explore All Knit In A Box Surprise Knitting Boxes
Little Skein in the Big Wool
This US-based company offers story-themed beginner-friendly knitting kits that are perfect for all knitters. While not a traditional subscription, their surprise boxes are highly giftable and unique.
What’s Inside:
- Hand-dyed yarn in exclusive colorways
- Story-inspired patterns
- Coordinated notions and accessories
Best for:
- Beginner and experienced knitters
- Book lovers and whimsical gifters
Why We Like It:
- Beautifully themed and packaged
- Ideal for fans of storytelling and craft
- Feels like an adventure in a box
👉 Visit Website
Crochet Society
Though designed primarily for crochet fans, Crochet Society’s surprise boxes are often adored by knitters who enjoy exploring new techniques or gifting across crafts. Each box is like a hug in the post.
What’s Inside:
- Exclusive yarns
- Hook/tools
- Illustrated patterns
- Surprise extras and goodies
Best for:
- Beginners branching into crochet
- Gifting across knitting and crochet
Why We Like It:
- Bright and joyful packaging
- Great crossover box for crafters
- Always includes fun surprises
👉 Visit Website
Cookston Crafts
Cookston Crafts offers both subscription options and themed one-off boxes, all handmade and carefully curated. Their packaging and presentation make them ideal for gifting.
What’s Inside:
- Hand-dyed yarns
- Seasonal or themed patterns
- Coordinated stitch markers and accessories
Best for:
- Creative gifters
- Yarn lovers who enjoy something a little different
Why We Like It:
- Supports small UK-based makers
- Each box is personal and unique
- Excellent variety of colourways and projects
👉 Visit Website
Stitches & Cream
This Cornwall-based yarn shop delivers monthly knitting kits that feel artisanal and luxurious. Their surprise boxes often include British yarns and unique project ideas.
What’s Inside:
- Natural fibre yarns (often British spun)
- Exclusive patterns
- Artisan tools or extras
Best for:
- Conscious consumers
- Fans of slow crafting and natural fibres
Why We Like It:
- Premium-quality, local yarns
- Gorgeous packaging with a boutique feel
- Perfect for mindful, cosy gifting
👉 Visit Website
Hebridean Tea Store Yarn Club
An unexpected but delightful gift option, this box combines the relaxing powers of tea with yarn, making it a sensory experience for knitters.
What’s Inside:
- Hand-dyed yarn
- Matching loose-leaf teas
- Project patterns
- Coordinated extras
Best for:
- Mindful knitters
- Tea and yarn lovers
Why We Like It:
- Calming and creative in equal measure
- Beautiful colour and flavour pairings
- Great for slow evenings and self-care
👉 Visit Website
Dina’s Home of Crafts
With a focus on hand-dyed yarns and small-batch items, Dina’s surprise boxes are perfect for yarn collectors and adventurous knitters.
What’s Inside:
- Luxury yarns
- Exclusive patterns or stitch guides
- Matching accessories
Best for:
- Fibre lovers
- Special occasion gifting
Why We Like It:
- Truly unique colourways and fibres
- Ideal for knitters who love discovering indie yarn
- Feels high-end but personal
👉 Visit Website
Lauren Aston Designs
Known for her bold, modern approach to knitting, Lauren Aston’s kits are vibrant, fun, and packed with personality, making them ideal for gifting someone who likes statement projects.
What’s Inside:
- Chunky yarn in striking colours
- Knitting pattern
- Optional needles and extras
Best for:
- Beginners knitters
- Colour lovers
Why We Like It:
- Bright and beginner-friendly
- Great for bold, modern projects
- Projects work up quickly and look amazing
👉 Visit Website
How to Choose the Right Surprise Knitting Box for a Gift
-
Check the recipient’s skill level: Some boxes are made for beginners with easy instructions, while others cater to experienced knitters who enjoy a challenge.
-
Look for gift-ready packaging: Choose boxes that arrive beautifully wrapped, with recyclable packaging and the option to include a personal note (Knit In A Box is a great choice).
-
Match the yarn type to their preferences: Consider whether they prefer chunky yarns, hand-dyed skeins, or natural fibres like merino or alpaca.
-
Decide between one-off vs. monthly delivery: A one-time box makes a great special occasion gift, while a subscription keeps the surprise going month after month.
-
Choose a theme that fits their style: Whether they love baby knits, home décor, or wearable accessories, pick a box that reflects their taste.
-
Check what’s included in the box: Some kits are all-in-one (yarn, needles, patterns, extras), while others might require additional tools.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a surprise knitting box?
A surprise knitting box is a curated gift box that includes yarn, patterns, and often tools or accessories, all selected around a theme and sent without revealing the exact contents in advance. They’re perfect for knitters who enjoy a creative challenge or want to discover new materials and projects.
Are these knitting boxes suitable for beginners?
Many of the boxes listed offer beginner-friendly options or include clear instructions and all the materials needed. Look for brands like Knit In A Box, which are known for accessible projects.
Can I buy just one box as a gift, or do I need to subscribe?
Most companies (such as Knit In A Box) offer both one-off boxes and subscriptions. One-off purchases are ideal for gifts, while subscriptions suit long-term hobbyists who enjoy receiving a surprise monthly knitting delivery.
What makes surprise knitting boxes a good gift?
These knitting boxes are beautifully packaged and thoughtfully curated, often including exclusive items and themes. They save time on shopping for individual components and feel like a personal, creative treat for the recipient.
